One site owner's view on comments

http://pando.com/2014/08/19/comment-sections-are-on-their-way-out/

Authored by: Bryan Goldberg.

Bryan is an entrepreneur in New York and San Francisco. He is the Founder and CEO of Bustle.com. He previously founded Bleacher Report, and currently advises several startups.

Major achievements, but it does not mean that he's correct on commenting systems.

No one method exists for managing user-contributed comments, especially with comments.

I have no problem with sites that prohibit comments. Nothing exists that says sites must permit user-contributed comment. It's a big web. Users can comment by other means, like with their own blog sites.

I take some exceptions with Bryan's views about comments.

... time has shown that comment sections often create a negative space and provide a negative experience — to the reader, the writer, and to the publisher.

Incorrect. Comment sections provide the experience mentioned above if a site owner permits it. You reap what you invest into the site. Like Anil Dash said, if your site has assholes, it's the site owner's fault. Quit blaming comments or user-contributed content. It's a lazy, unimaginative excuse.

If you don't want to permit comments, then simply say that managing comments in way that we like takes too much innovation and time, and we feel that energy is best used on other aspects of our site. Twitter can be the web's message board.